Incentive vs. Bonus vs. Commission: Which One is Best?

Your compensation strategy can shape how your team performs and grows! Money conversations and picking the right way to pay your people will either fire them up or leave them feeling flat. Sure, you can follow basic salaries, but mixing in some extras like bonuses or commissions gets people moving.

Think about what actually lights up your employees. Some people can sprint harder when you dangle a commission in front of them. Others are at their best when they know a big bonus is waiting at the finish line! You’ll need different approaches for different people – what works for your sales team probably won’t motivate your tech crew.

Think about the practical reality of running your business. Your sales crew might crush it with pure commission, while your support team needs the security of a steady paycheck with bonus opportunities.

They need different approaches based on what kind of behavior you want to encourage – this also depends on what your team usually prefers. You need to keep everything fair and clear – nobody likes a confusing pay structure that leaves them guessing.

Let’s explore these three options and see which fits best!

#1. Incentive Plans

You want to get the best results from your team and incentive programs are a useful way to get them! Think of these programs as your game plan – you set some goals and you can now watch your people get rewarded when they hit them. These rewards help keep your employees focused and excited about their work. They’re also more likely to stick around longer.

You have two main ways to reward your people – money and everything else. The money side features bonuses at the end of the year, a slice of company profits, or sales commissions. Cash rewards work great for quick wins! When you meet a target, you get paid right away.

But money isn’t everything. Your team might value other benefits more than you’d think. Give them an extra day off, public recognition for a job well done, or real team experiences. Some businesses even throw in gym memberships or wellness programs. These non-cash rewards usually mean more to people than straight-up money.

Looking to learn more about an incentive, rebate
or reward program for your business?

Curious about costs?

Try our instant pricing calculator:


1 Incentive Plans

Sales teams love incentives called SPIFFs – quick rewards for hitting specific targets. Your customers aren’t left out, either! You’ve probably seen those “spend $100, get $20 back” deals. That’s an incentive program that is working its magic to keep people coming back.

Look around different industries, and you’ll see all sorts of creative reward systems in place. Retail stores hand out points and discounts to loyal shoppers. Tech businesses reward their people for launching innovative new products. Hospitals give bonuses when patient satisfaction scores increase. Even factories get in on the action with profit-sharing when production goals are crushed.

The best part? You can combine and match these rewards to fit your exact needs. Maybe your team lights up at the thought of extra vacation days. Or maybe they’re all about those performance bonuses. Smart businesses find what makes their people tick and build their incentives around that.

They’re about keeping everyone excited about reaching the same goals, whether that’s through cash, recognition, or fun experiences. When you nail this, your whole team wins – and so does your bottom line.

#2. Bonus Structures

Your company can reward you with two different types of bonuses. These are performance-based and discretionary! Performance bonuses are easy – hit goals, and you’ll get paid extra. Maybe you need to close a number of sales, keep your customers happy, or finish some projects on time. You’ll always know exactly what you need to earn these bonuses – they appear in your paycheck at set times throughout the year.

Think about it this way – your sales team crushes their monthly target – extra money in their next paycheck! Or maybe you wrapped up that giant project ahead of schedule – that’s another chance to earn some bonus cash.

2 Bonus Structures

Now, discretionary bonuses work differently. Your boss decides when and if you get these – there’s no checklist to follow. These can pop up based on how well the company is doing or when someone goes above and beyond. You might get surprised with a holiday bonus or some extra cash for handling a crisis like an expert.

The odds of getting a performance bonus depend on hitting specific targets – pretty clear-cut facts. But discretionary bonuses are about catching your boss’s eye with exceptional work. Either way, these extra payments motivate employees. Performance bonuses push you toward specific targets. Surprise bonuses keep everyone motivated without creating stress about hitting exact numbers.

Smart businesses match their bonus system to their goals. Want to boost sales? Throw some performance bonuses at your sales team when they exceed their targets. Looking to build a stronger company culture? Use those discretionary bonuses to reward people who step up in unexpected ways.

#3. Commission Plans

Your paycheck directly goes hand in hand with your sales performance through commission-based pay. You’ll earn more money when you close more deals! Sales teams love this setup because you’re in control of your income. Think of it as a slice of every sale that you make – that sparks a fire under you to succeed.

Here’s how the math usually works out – You can pocket a percentage of what you sell. If you sell $30,000 worth of products at a 5% commission, then you’ve just earned yourself $1,500. You’ll find different types of commission structures out there. Some businesses put all your earnings in the commission basket – you eat what you kill (as they say). No base salary, just pure commission.

Most organizations combine it with a base salary plus commission deal. You get a steady paycheck to cover the bills – plus extra cash when you crush your sales goals! Some businesses even sweeten the deal with graduated commissions – sell more and earn a bigger percentage. Others might put a ceiling on what you can earn to keep costs in check.

3 Commission Plans

Sales roles and commission pay go together like peanut butter and jelly. You’re rewarded for hustling and bringing in business – that matches what the company wants. Talented salespeople flock to commission-based jobs because they know they can make serious money.

Commission plans benefit everyone involved. The company grows when you sell more, and you take home bigger paychecks. Your success directly drives the company’s growth!

The relationship between motivation and commission-based pay speaks volumes. You’ll work harder because every sale puts more cash in your pocket. The best part? Businesses can roll with the changes and adjust commission structures when the market changes or new products launch.

You’ll also step up your customer service game because satisfied customers mean more sales – and more money for you. Businesses favor this setup because they only pay out when deals actually close and they keep their fixed costs under control.

Advantages and Disadvantages

You can improve your team’s performance through different reward systems! Each one has its own pros and cons. Let’s break down how bonuses, commissions, and other useful benefits actually work in real life.

The employees stay way more focused when they know exactly what they’re working toward. When you set clear targets ahead of time, all your team members can map out their own path to success! You might even hand out some surprise rewards now and then to keep spirits high. Your reward system needs crystal-clear rules, or you’ll end up with frustrated workers who feel cheated.

Bonuses can pack a different kind of punch than regular commission checks. Your staff will probably stick around longer when they know a good year-end bonus is coming their way. The steady bonus payments help your people plan their finances better than up-and-down commission checks do. Team bonuses work best when you want everyone pulling together instead of competing. Watch out, though – yearly bonuses might not motivate people like weekly commission checks do.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Commission-based pay puts the power right in your team’s hands – sell more, earn more. Easy as that. Sales superstars love this setup because they can earn big rewards when they’re on fire. The downside? Your people might stress out about their unpredictable income, and you might see some office drama when the competition gets too heated. Sometimes, people even bend the rules just to hit their numbers.

Mix and match these different pay styles to create something that works. Think about combining base pay, regular bonuses, and commission opportunities. Your top sellers can chase big commission checks while everyone else still feels protected with their steady income. Just make sure your reward system aligns with your company’s needs. You don’t want your sales team chasing commission dollars if it hurts your company’s reputation or long-term success.

But there’s no perfect system that works for every business! Play around with different combinations until you find what clicks with your team and your company goals.

The Best Approach

You need to think about how your bonuses and commissions can fit into your company’s situation. Different types of pay methods work better for different types of businesses – they shine when matched correctly!

Look at some tech businesses – you’ll need to pay more because skilled workers are in high demand – make sure you can check what other businesses are paying each year. When you run a smaller company? You might not have the same budget. But you can give useful benefits like working from home instead. Bigger businesses have more options – you could even tie the pay to how much profit each department makes.

Your office staff probably works best with a regular salary since their work stays steady day to day. But for your sales team, a mixed salary with commission gives them extra drive to close deals. Some salespeople actually like working pure commission (they know their paycheck directly relates to their effort). And when you have teams working together on big projects, team bonuses can get everyone pulling in the same direction!

You’ll pay more for employees with better education and more experience – that’s just how it works. Let’s talk about location – you’ll need to pay more in expensive cities than in smaller areas.

Bonuses improve motivation for specific targets – they get everyone excited about hitting goals. You can predict exactly what you’ll pay since you set the terms first. Commission works differently – your sales team could earn quite a bit when sales are strong. But their income might bounce around quite a bit.

The Best Approach

Want to welcome other positive behaviors? Try giving some incentives for achievements past sales numbers – this helps create stronger connections with your brand.

You’ll see success when your pay strategy aligns with your market goals. Want to be the industry leader? You’ll need to pay more than your competitors. Ask your employees what they think about their pay – their opinions matter. Watch how people quit, too. People leaving might mean you need to rethink your strategy.

When you talk about strategy – you have to be crystal clear about how people get paid. Everyone needs to know exactly how it works or they’ll start thinking it’s unfair. Keep everything steady. But be ready to change plans when needed.

Remember to follow what you can actually afford – promising more than your budget allows will only cause problems later.

Finally, you can use bonuses to create some friendly competition with your non-sales teams and save commissions for the people bringing in the revenue.

Level Up Your Incentives and Rewards

Money drives action – plain and easy! You need to know exactly how incentives, bonuses, and commissions can work differently so you can pick what’s best for your business. Incentives can give you lots of wiggle room to welcome the activities you want from your employees, from selling more to making customers happier. Bonuses help keep your team motivated for the long haul since they know they’ll get rewarded when they hit their targets. Commissions light a fire under your sales team because they can earn more money right away when they close deals.

You should try to match your compensation strategy with what your business is trying to accomplish and how your company culture operates. The way you pay your people affects everything – from how hard they work to how long they stick around! Once you see how each payment style motivates people differently, you can build a compensation plan that gets results. When you strike that balance between motivation and budget, your business thrives.

Level Up Your Incentives and Rewards

Take a look at the different positions in your company – think about which payment style works best for each role! Maybe you want incentives to spark some new ideas from your creative team. Or maybe bonuses will help keep your core staff loyal and committed. Your sales team might hustle harder with some commission-based pay. Whatever combination you choose needs to align well with your company’s goals.

Level 6 knows how to boost your business with proven incentive programs. We drive up sales numbers, boost employee satisfaction, and strengthen teams. Our services feature everything from branded debit cards to employee recognition programs and sales incentives. These are all customized to fit what your organization needs! We don’t just copy and paste services – we create programs that drive real growth for your company. Let’s set up a free demo and show you how we help businesses exceed their sales goals and maximize their ROI.