When it comes time to roll out an incentive plan, you’ll inevitably have to pick between an annual or a regular incentive plan.
The choice between these two can improve some of your employees’ motivation. And one very well may work better than the other. The idea is that when you connect each person’s work to the goals of your company’s bigger picture, everyone naturally moves in the same direction. They also start to feel like they are part of a team that’s winning together.
But you’ll need to have a flexible reward system – especially in a workplace that’s always changing. And with the right kind of incentive plan, the goal is for you to improve morale and engagement. There are other factors like fairness, flexibility, and recognition that I’ll talk about. All of these factors affect how your team performs.
Let’s talk about how you can energize your team and rethink your strategy!
The Purpose Of Annual Incentives
Yearly bonus plans are a part of how you and your team can work to shoot for success. They also help you focus on long-term goals instead of just short-term fixes! Big businesses like Microsoft use these bonus programs to encourage steady performance, and you can see why that kind of setup matters.
When there’s a big bonus waiting at the end of the year, you naturally start to make more thoughtful decisions. You might stay away from snappy sales and risky shortcuts that could hurt the company later on. It helps you build stronger customer relationships and creates growth that lasts longer.
You might see that waiting for a yearly bonus can give you some extra drive at work. Some colleagues feel motivated by the promise of that large reward. However, others might find it harder to stay completely involved when the finish line feels distant. Still, every one of you goes through that wait during the year – which has its own energy and challenges.
Business leaders like annual incentives because they make the process of planning and handling budgets easier. They get to set clear targets early in the year and also check progress along the way. This kind of setup lets you adjust your work to meet regular feedback, as well as changes in the market. This helps create a workplace where everyone knows where they stand.
Looking to learn more about an incentive, rebate
or reward program for your business?
DemoCurious about costs?
Try our instant pricing calculator:
At the same time, you might find that the yearly bonus system has a few drawbacks. Some workers might take it slower at the start and just rush near the end to hit targets. You could also see that the pressure this creates sometimes leaves customers feeling unsatisfied.
Even so, annual plans help you keep your best talents around. Large year-end bonuses make it harder for competitors to snatch away team members (because you feel legitimately liked). You feel you have a reason to stay committed for the long haul.
At the end of the day, these bonus systems remind you to keep your eye on the bigger picture. When you’re building long-term relationships and working toward reliable ways to serve your customers, this can give you better results for your team and the company.
How It Affects Talent And Retention
Annual incentive plans work in a fun way by celebrating your best team members. You can feel the excitement when a giant bonus check is waiting for you at the end of the year instead of finding small rewards along the way! This big finish is what you look forward to. Some businesses even say that giving this type of yearly prize brings better results compared to handing out rewards every single month.
You can start to feel more motivated when you hear that a reward is coming your way at the end of the year. You build excitement in each quarter as you push yourself for even better results. That can give you one goal to go after.
You might see that not all feedback about annual incentives is positive, though. Some of your colleagues might feel frustrated because they wait a long time to get their rewards. This delay sometimes causes talented people to look for opportunities elsewhere with organizations that give rewards more often.
You can see this lesson in action from businesses like General Electric. They experienced top performers leaving their company, so they switched to quarterly bonuses. This change meant that you and your stars received more regular recognition. It helped the company hold on to its best talent as turnover stayed low.
You also get a better workplace when everyone shares that same big yearly goal. Annual bonuses allow you to work together toward an achievement everyone looks forward to. Monthly or quarterly rewards sometimes lead you to chase quick wins instead of focusing more on long-term success. You find that when conversations about money happen at the right time, they can improve morale.
Studies have shown that businesses with annual incentives retain employees for about 18 months longer than the ones with more regular bonus payouts. But you might see that younger workers like quicker and regular rewards.
You’re in the midst of a changing workplace, and the way people expect to be rewarded is changing, too. While some of you grow on the excitement of a big year-end bonus, others want more regular recognition to stay involved. Organizations are finding that combining these strategies could be the answer to keeping everyone excited and involved.
Why Frequent Incentives Matter
Regular incentive plans have become a bit more popular recently, and it’s pretty easy to see why! You can seem naturally uplifted when you get to be recognized for your hard work. When the rewards come on a monthly or even a quarterly basis, you get to enjoy regular celebrations that can brighten up your work year.
Think about how great it feels when you can get an unexpected bonus or even an extra day off. This could be not long after completing a big project. These quick wins spark a kind of excitement. They also make your day-to-day work feel way more rewarding. The promise of upcoming rewards can even make your scheduled tasks feel a little more worthwhile.
Managers also like regular incentives because they keep in touch with their team’s progress. They can catch problems early and adjust their plans – this works way better when dealing with clear and quick feedback.
Regular rewards do come with a bit more paperwork and extra organization. So businesses have to choose if the extra work is worth the improvement in team spirit. You might see that some people feel overwhelmed by regular targets, which could distract them from focusing on their main duties.
Different teams respond in different ways to how often rewards are given. Just to give an example, you might see that sales teams grow on monthly commissions that match their environment. Creative teams like quarterly bonuses that fit with their longer projects.
Our brains also respond well to more regular positive feedback. You light up when receiving immediate recognition, which (as you would probably expect) motivates better performance. Regular rewards help you feel appreciated throughout the year instead of only during an annual review.
Businesses that use regular incentives often see stronger employee retention. Workers can seem more motivated when they’re continuously acknowledged. This steady recognition can create a feedback loop that helps keep your enthusiasm and performance at a high level.
Fair And Inclusive Incentive Structures
You might see that annual incentive plans sometimes miss a big part of the picture – they sometimes forget about the full picture of workplace fairness. The businesses basically have the raw performance numbers and forget about the wider results of each person’s work – that means you could end up with situations where the hardworking team members who contribute in soft ways never receive the recognition they deserve. See the sales team member who helps others to close their deals.
You can see that their own sales figures don’t tell the whole story because their support helps the entire team’s performance. The behind-the-scenes work they do plays a big part in driving success! However, traditional review systems sometimes forget about the results they add.
You also need to look at the obvious and hidden types of bias in your workplace. Sometimes, the way you measure performance ends up favoring some groups without you even realizing it. Just to give you an example, sales targets that ignore the differences in territory sizes or market conditions can put some workers at a disadvantage. You might not see the inequity until it’s too late.
It helps to get some feedback from everyone who works on your team. Employees sometimes find problems that you might miss in your day-to-day work. You can use their input to build incentive plans that feel fairer for everyone involved. Their feedback helps you to make adjustments so the rewards feel real across the board.
You might feel tempted to think that switching to more regular incentive plans, like monthly rewards, could solve these challenges. But if these plans aren’t designed well, they might actually worsen bias by pushing people toward short-term wins instead of encouraging teamwork and long-term growth. That change in focus can hurt the health of your organization.
At the end of the day, what matters is finding ways to measure and reward the different types of success. Some of your team members are great at customer service. But others are at their best when solving tough problems. Each type of contribution deserves its own kind of recognition in a fair system that sees value in all work.
Stories from real people can also help open your eyes to hidden flaws in the most recent plans. See Julianne, who managed backend operations for a sales team. But she never qualified for sales bonuses because the system didn’t account for her contributions.
You should also make it a habit to review your incentive plans for any unintended effects on different groups of employees. When you check how rewards are distributed across teams, roles, and demographics, it helps you find any unfair patterns. When you take action early, you can fix these problems before they grow into bigger ones that affect your entire organization. When you forget these roles, it can hurt team morale and even drive talented workers away.
Flexible Plans In Changing Markets
Businesses need to make their incentive plans more flexible – especially when the market changes this fast. You can see how fixed reward systems might actually backfire when the business conditions start to change! The COVID-19 pandemic taught us that sticking tightly to rigid bonus plans can leave everyone in a tough place. You might have seen how some businesses were forced to choose between setting unreachable targets or abandoning their bonus programs altogether.
This left employees feeling even more overwhelmed during an already stressful and tough time. That’s why you should consider changing up your incentive options instead of sticking to just one fixed idea.
An example comes from a retail chain that switched its focus and also its entire strategy. They stopped pushing sales based only on gaining new customers. Instead, they chose to reward work that was put into keeping their existing customers satisfied. That small difference helped with team spirit and also built stronger, long-term customer relationships.
When budgets shrink, the traditional bonus plans might not work anymore. If you completely drop incentives, it can sap employee motivation during the worst possible time. So start looking for creative alternatives like extra vacation days or other kinds of non-cash rewards. These can help improve morale without straining the budget too much.
Clear and direct communication can become even more of a big deal when you make changes to your incentive plans. Everyone needs to know what they’re working toward and why the changes are being made. When some items are left vague, it can add to the stress and uncertainty you might already be feeling.
You also want to start changing how often the rewards are actually given. Annual bonuses work well when situations are steady. However, more regular rewards might help keep focus and energy levels high during more turbulent times. Short-term achievements can really matter when long-term goals start to feel out of reach.
Finally, you should always ask for some regular feedback on your incentive plans. What seems good on paper doesn’t work as well in reality.
Level Up Your Incentives and Rewards
Your incentive strategy needs to find a balance between your own long-term vision and the motivation that fuels your team. From years of working with sales teams, I found that breaking down annual targets into smaller and manageable quarterly milestones can help everyone stay completely involved. They can still keep an eye on the bigger picture. You can see how your team often responds in different ways when they can see immediate rewards. They don’t have to wait for long-term incentives to come through.
Finding the right combination of incentive programs isn’t always easy. You might worry about the extra administrative tasks or even the burnout that comes from regular check-ins. And it’s natural to think that an annual plan might give you enough progress in the meantime. The value of modern incentive programs is in their flexibility. So you can change or fine-tune your strategy to better match your team’s culture and your business needs.
When you set out to build some sort of incentive strategy, you can try Level 6. We specialize in taking your business to new heights with a few customized incentive programs. You’ll see increases in your sales performance as well as better employee morale and improved satisfaction. Our services feature branded debit cards, employee rewards, recognition programs, and customized sales incentive programs. They’re all designed specifically with your goals in mind.
Reach out to us for a free demo to see how we help successful businesses expand their ROI and drive stronger sales results!
Claudine is the Chief Relationship Officer at Level 6. She holds a master’s degree in industrial/organizational psychology. Her experience includes working as a certified conflict mediator for the United States Postal Service, a human performance analyst for Accenture, an Academic Dean, and a College Director. She is currently an adjunct Professor of Psychology at Southern New Hampshire University. With over 20 years of experience, she joined Level 6 to guide clients seeking effective ways to change behavior and, ultimately, their bottom line.
